The rapid advancement of artificial intelligence is raising significant ethical concerns, particularly regarding human agency. As AI technology evolves, the challenge remains to ensure it aligns with human values without compromising individual decision-making.
A historical debate between two ancient sages, Rabbi Eliezer and Rabbi Yoshua, illustrates this dilemma. Rabbi Eliezer claimed divine support for his legal interpretations through miraculous acts, yet was ultimately overruled by Rabbi Yoshua, who emphasized human judgment over celestial endorsement. This ancient discourse highlights the importance of human agency in decision-making.
Current discussions among experts, including figures like Eliezer Yudkowsky and Yoshua Bengio, echo the need for a framework that preserves human choice in the face of advancing AI. True alignment with human values necessitates addressing not only technical challenges but also profound philosophical questions about the nature of meaning in decision-making.